• News
  • World Media

Low-Fat, Low-Carb Diet Study Shows They Work About the Same

Low-Fat, Low-Carb Diet Study Shows They Work About the Same

The randomized investigation (which is important) by Stanford University researchers assigned 609 overweight but otherwise healthy participants to a low-fat or low-carb diet and followed them for 12 months. "But it failed", Gardner says.

U.S. academics were attempting to end the long-running controversy over the merits of low-fat versus low-carbohydrate diets.

"At the end of the year, people on the low-fat diet lost an average of nearly 12 pounds, compared with about 13 pounds for the low-carb diet". What really matters is your relationship to food going forward. A string of studies have found that the average person fares about as well on one diet as they do on the other.

"I had this whole rationale for why these three [DNA variants] would have an effect", said study co-author Christopher Gardner, citing a 2010 study he conducted that suggested genotypes could be the key to weight loss. To help curb mindless snacking, educators also told people to stop eating in their vehicle or in front of their television and to make an effort to routinely dine with friends and family, shop at farmers' markets and cook at home. Neither genetic predisposition nor insulin resistance was helpful in identifying which diet was better for whom, according to the study.

While that may be frustrating news for dieters, Gardner says there is a silver lining to the finding.

Additionally, the scientists found that there were no significant diet-insulin or diet-genotype interactions.

The individuals enrolled in this study may have "cheated, " Dr. Apovian suggests, by not adhered completely to the low-fat or low-carb plan.




Gardner discusses the results of the study in the video below. Now, the popular message is "eat less carbs".

Sure, it seems like a good idea: Lose weight following a diet that's tailored to your own unique genetic makeup instead of trying a one-size-fits-all approach.

Even though cutting calories wasn't a goal for these dieters, people might still achieve this by replacing junk food with healthier alternatives, said Kevin Hall, a researcher at the National Institute of Diabetes and Digestive and Kidney Diseases who wasn't involved in the study. Some lost a lot more weight than others - 60 pounds or more, while others actually gained weight. What might have worked differently for the more successful losers?

Individual results after a year were quite varied - one person lost 60 pounds, while another gained 20 - but the average weight loss in each group was nearly identical: 11 pounds in the low-fat group, compared to 13 pounds in the low-carb group.

In short, we hypothesized that we would be able to use information from previous studies of the past decade to come up with factors that we could test that would help determine which diet is better for whom.
Rather, it has much more to do with behavior change: "mindfulness, putting the fork down, not eating in front of the screen, going to the farmer's market, cooking meals".

The people who lost the most weight said it wasn't so much what they ate, as how they thought about food.

Disclosure s : The authors report no relevant financial disclosures. Dr. Apovian has participated on advisory boards for Amylin, Merck, Johnson and Johnson, Arena, Nutrisystem, Zafgen, Sanofi-Aventis, Orexigen, EnteroMedics, Scientific Intake and Novo Nordisk and she is on the Takeda Speakers' Bureau for the medication Contrave and has an ownership interest in Science Smart LLC.

Leave Your Comment

Leave Your Comment


Latest News

  • Samsung unveils world's largest SSD with whopping 30TB of storage

    Samsung unveils world's largest SSD with whopping 30TB of storage

    Now this year, Samsung is taking it a step further with the new " PM1643 ", a 30TB SSD built on the latest 512Gb V-NAND. Sequential read and write speeds of up to 2100 MBPS and 1700 MBPS respectively were recorded in tests done by Samsung.
    New South African Leader Pledges Economic and Political Turnaround

    New South African Leader Pledges Economic and Political Turnaround

    On Wednesday, eight members of the powerful and wealthy Gupta family were arrested and accused of fraud and money laundering. New President Cyril Ramaphosa (center) said he would concentrate on creating jobs and attracting investment.
    The Flu Isn't Playing Around This Year. Here's How to Fight Back

    The Flu Isn't Playing Around This Year. Here's How to Fight Back

    Caused by viruses, flu is a contagious respiratory illness with mild to severe symptoms that can sometimes lead to death. Gottlieb said scientists at the FDA, CDC and National Institutes of Health are trying to understand why.
  • Kanye West makes his return to social media

    Kanye West makes his return to social media

    The rapper first posted a photo of a card he gave his wife Kim Kardashian that read "Happy Valentine's Day Babe". West is known for doing random and surprising things, and his Instagram posting spree is no exception.
    All-New 2019 BMW X4 Coupe-Style SUV Arrives this Year

    All-New 2019 BMW X4 Coupe-Style SUV Arrives this Year

    This means it'll accelerate from 0-62mph in just 4.8 seconds and return an advertised 44.1mpg and 170g/km of CO2. The new BMW also receives Hill Descent Control and Hill Start Assist systems, as standard.
    Prince Harry & Meghan Markle's wedding: what we know so far

    Prince Harry & Meghan Markle's wedding: what we know so far

    Their trip to Edinburgh ended with a reception at the Palace of Holyroodhouse for the Scottish Government's Year of Young People . The Prince and Meghan Markle stepped out in Edinburgh for their first Royal visit to the country north of England at lunchtime.
  • Flu Cases Nearing Numbers From 2009 Swine Flu Outbreak

    Flu Cases Nearing Numbers From 2009 Swine Flu Outbreak

    It's not too late to get a flu shot , but McMahan suggested people first call their doctor or pharmacist to check availability. There have been record-breaking numbers this season in Oklahoma with 3,440 flu-associated hospitalizations, and 153 deaths.
    Commerce Dept. backs tariffs on imported aluminum and steel

    Commerce Dept. backs tariffs on imported aluminum and steel

    Warning China, Trump said Beijing has decimated the American steel and aluminium industry and he is "considering all options". China is by far the largest producer and exporter of steel, and the largest source of excess steel capacity.
    Sweden's Kalla wins first gold of PyeongChang 2018

    Sweden's Kalla wins first gold of PyeongChang 2018

    Chinese skier Lixin clocked in 46:01.9 to finish 51st while her teammate Chi Chunxue settled for the 55th in 46:39.0. Kalla has now equalled canoeist Agneta Andersson as the Swedish woman with the most Olympic gold medals, with three.
  • Eurosceptic MPs pile pressure on UK's premier over Brexit

    Eurosceptic MPs pile pressure on UK's premier over Brexit

    The letter, organised by the European Research Group of euroskeptic Tories, is a potentially destabilizing development at a highly sensitive time for May's Brexit preparations.
    AAP MLA Prakash Jarwal taken into custody by Delhi Police

    AAP MLA Prakash Jarwal taken into custody by Delhi Police

    Deputy CM Manish Sisodia , however, reiterated that the chief secretary's allegations were "baseless". Chief minister Arvind Kejriwal was present at the meeting, but maintained silence on the controversy.
    Fox, ESPN battling to sign Peyton Manning to a broadcasting deal

    Fox, ESPN battling to sign Peyton Manning to a broadcasting deal

    According to Andrew Marchand of the New York Post , a source said ESPN is willing to "back up the truck' for the five-time MVP". Prior to last season, FOX reached out to Manning with the idea of either an in-studio or booth job on the table.
  • Emotional win for Bubba at Riviera

    Emotional win for Bubba at Riviera

    On opposite coasts, Bubba Watson and Joe Durant produced unique history Sunday in Pensacola's extensive professional golf legacy. Had his bunker shot on 14 snuck by the pin, it would have rolled out several feet, leaving a hard comebacker for par.
    Facebook to use U.S.  mail to try and prevent future election meddling

    Facebook to use U.S. mail to try and prevent future election meddling

    US President Donald Trump stands with National Rifle Association Executive Vice President Wayne LaPierre, R, and Chris W. They were equipped with cameras, SIM cards, drop phones and, if needed, "evacuation scenarios", the indictment says.
    Israel Shells Gaza with Tank Fire after 'Device Explodes' Injuring 4 Soldiers

    Israel Shells Gaza with Tank Fire after 'Device Explodes' Injuring 4 Soldiers

    Later, IDF and Gaza officials reported a series of Israeli airstrikes against terror training sites and tunnels. According to reports in Gaza, shots were fired at a Hamas compound east of the southern city of Khan Yunis.
  • Don't Buy that Galaxy S8 Just Yet, Price Is About to Drop

    Don't Buy that Galaxy S8 Just Yet, Price Is About to Drop

    Somehow the Galaxy Note 8 cost the same on contract as the S8 Plus past year , but we're expecting a small uplift for the S9 Plus. The latest leaks bring the official promotional renders as well as pricing for some European countries.
    Xiaomi May Launches MI TV on Valentine's Day

    Xiaomi May Launches MI TV on Valentine's Day

    On the front is a 20-megapixel Sony IMX376 sensor with f/2.2 aperture, AI-based Beautify 4.0 and LED selfie-light. The device comes with a hybrid SIM card slot and lets you choose between a secondary SIM card or a MicroSD card.
    Iraq Requires $88.2bn For Reconstruction - Minister

    Iraq Requires $88.2bn For Reconstruction - Minister

    The US appreciates the "generous contributions" of coalition members over the past year but more is needed, Tillerson said. As a result of the implementation of projects Turkey will propose, many Iraqis will have jobs and be able to return home.

Breaking News



Recommended

Russian Federation denies responsibility for eastern Ghouta deaths

But Hayat Tahrir al-Sham, a jihadist alliance led by al-Qaeda's former affiliate in Syria, also operates there. The Turks have crossed the border to push back the Kurds in northern Syria.

Volvo V60: This is it!

First introduced in Europe back in 2010 before it came to America in 2014, the Swedish station wagon is overdue an update. For the first time, City Safety includes a feature which enables automatic braking to mitigate an oncoming collision.

David Padgett to speak after Louisville loses 2013 national championship banner

Pitino was placed on administrative leave on September 27 and then fired with "just cause" on October 16. David Padgett has been serving as Louisville's acting head coach since Pitino's departure.

Heavy storm hits New Zealand

Dozens of schools have been shut and roads closed on the South Island as the storm made landfall on Tuesday, the BBC reports. New Zealand's national airline has cancelled all flights in and out of the capital, Wellington , on North Island.

Law Firm Associate Charged With Lying To Mueller

Deputy Trump campaign aide Rick Gates, center, departs federal court in Washington , Monday, Dec. 11, 2017. He also made false statements about his conversations with someone identified as 'Person A'.

Highline College on lockdown after reports of gunfire

Kent Assistant Police Chief Rafael Padilla said authorities walked the entire Highline College campus and did not find anything. School officials ended the lockdown just before noon after being told by law enforcement that the situation was "all clear".

Mitt Romney announces US Senate run in Utah

Mr Romney, 70, will be the heavy favourite for the Senate seat being opened by senator Orrin Hatch's retirement. The path to victory is expected to be a clear one for Romney, who is considered a sure bet to replace Hatch.

Serena Williams says she's on the 'right track' after her comeback

"It was really special to be back out here with Venus and we're so happy Team USA won today", Williams told reporters . The dead-rubber was supposed to be the feel-good, icing on the cake, but the Dutch players had other ideas.

Indian billionaire named in PM graft case denies partnership with key suspect

However, Netanyahu, prime minister for almost 12 years has claimed innocence. Netanyahu draws political strength in part from his close ties with U.S.

Trump Urges Lawmakers to Make Deal on Immigration Reform

Senior Republican lawmakers say Trump deserves credit for the totality of his immigration proposal. Chuck Schumer said immigration won't be easy during remarks at the McConnell Center in Louisville.