• News
  • Research

United States high court hands disabled students win on education standards

United States high court hands disabled students win on education standards

The NPR report notes that Judge Neil Gorsuch, now in confirmation hearings to fill the vacant ninth seat on the court, has ruled in eight out of ten cases involving students with disabilities toward limiting the responsibilities of public school districts.

The Supreme Court on Wednesday unanimously raised the bar for the educational benefits owed to millions of children with disabilities in one of the most significant special-education cases to reach the high court in decades.

Gorsuch's interpretation was pursuant to which a school district satisfies federal law, and does not need to reimburse the cost of private education, so long as it provides educational benefits to disabled students that are "more than de minimis". The District argued that it met this standard by creating a basic floor of opportunity for the disabled child, providing individualized services sufficient to provide him with some level of educational benefit.

The federal Individuals With Disabilities Education Act, or IDEA, guarantees a "free appropriate public education" to all students with disabilities.

Instead, the court said special education must be "reasonably calculated to enable a child to make progress appropriate in light of the child's circumstances".

Gorsuch wrote the opinion for a unanimous 2008 decision in which he rejected the claim that the Colorado school district was not doing enough to educate the autistic student.

"For children with disabilities, receiving instruction that aims so low would be tantamount to 'sitting idly ... awaiting the time when they were old enough to drop out, '" he added, quoting from key 1982 Supreme Court precedent on special education, Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson Central School District v. Rowley, that also dealt with the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act. John Cornyn, he said "I was wrong, Senator, because I was bound by circuit precedent, and I'm sorry".

In Endrew's case his parents pulled him out of a public school in the county located near Denver, frustrated with his lack of progress.

"Please", Durbin said, no one was suggesting that, but a wrong reading of the law. They had argued that educational programs for disabled students should meet goals "substantially equal" to those for children without disabilities.

Gorsuch's opinions in eight out of 10 cases involving students of disabilities all tended toward limiting the responsibilities of school districts - for example, if they leave school of their own accord out of frustration. The achievement levels of students in special education are among the lowest in Alabama, on par with children who are just beginning to learn the English language. That year was especially rocky for Drew, as the school reported he climbed over furniture and other students, hit things, screamed, ran away from school, and twice removed his clothing and went to the bathroom on the floor of the classroom.

In a unanimous decision, the court ruled that the school did not violate the law based on the low standard set by longstanding judicial precedent. Gorsuch has been involved in over ten cases involving students with disabilities.

Leave Your Comment

Leave Your Comment

Latest News

Breaking News


Sheriff Darnell responds to ICE detainer report

Montgomery County, Iowa, and Snohomish County, Wash., both tied for fourth with 12 ignored detainer requests each. Detainers are made for aliens who are arrested in local jails that ICE believe should be removed from the U.S.

Joy Reid on Ivanka's move to the White House

The documents cited Kellyanne Conway who famously encouraged people to go buy Ivanka trump's clothing during a TV segment. He clarified Ivanka Trump will follow the ethics rules guiding all government employees, Daily Mail reports.

Bill Gates Net Worth 2017

Indiana's richest man got much wealthier over the past year, according to calculations released Monday by Forbes magazine . President Donald Trump comes in on the list at No. 544, with a net worth of $3.5 billion.

'Beauty and the Beast' enchants S. Korean box office

Well, that record has just been beaten, as Disney's remake of Beauty and the Beast took in $174.75 million this past weekend. Disney's Beauty And The Beast has smashed box office records both at home and overseas over its opening weekend.

How to Get Galaxy S8 Dream UI on Any Samsung Device Now

Bloomberg reports that the tech giant had acquired a patent for a way to "detect faces using information in digital video feeds". The technology will primarily be used in mobile payment services such as Samsung Pay to provide users with enhanced security.

Chelsea-Stoke City Preview

The defender pounced on a poor Erik Pieters clearance at a corner three minutes from time to reward Chelsea for their dominance. Antonio Conte's men are now 13 points clear at the top of the table with another hard fixture ticked off the calendar.

Yadira Arroyo: FDNY Medic Killed By Her Own Ambulance In Fatal Carjacking

While EMTs know their vital work can be risky , they don't expect violence, Fire Commissioner Daniel Nigro said Friday. A man has been charged with stealing an ambulance and killing an FDNY EMT by running her over Thursday night.

Meet Roger Federer, David Foster and the Backhand Boys

However, his withdrawal in Indian Wells means Federer advances to the final four, where he will face either Jack Sock or Kei Nishikori.

Seattle Seahawks to meet with former Green Bay TE Jared Cook

Rapoport calls this a "huge addition", and apparently that means the type of player who had 30 catches for 377 yards a year ago . Today the Raiders added to their already potent offensive arsenal by adding tight end Jared Cook .

Nadal beats Verdasco to reach Indian Wells' last 16

In a very tight first set, Federer edged out Nadal 7-5 to take the lead in the match . The Australian defeated German Alexander Zverev 6-3, 6-4 to book his California spot.